Peanut Butter Pie Recipe

Here is the Peanut Butter Pie recipe I mentioned in my last blog posting. And wow.. this pie was delicious! 


Peanut Butter Pie

Emily Miller


1 graham cracker crust (recipe follows)

1 ½ cups whole cream

2 oz cream cheese, softened

1 cup powdered Sucanat (can use powdered sugar), sift before measuring

1/3 cup half n half

1 t vanilla

1 cup peanut butter (made with peanuts only, chunky or smooth, your choice)

Chocolate syrup (for drizzling on top)


We make this in our Kitchen Aid and have two bowls for it and both were needed for this recipe. You could make this with a KA and if you have hand beaters that would be helpful for whipping the cream. If not, follow directions for whipping the cream and then transfer this into a bowl while you wash the bowl and move on to the second part.


Before you begin put a bowl and the beaters of your mixer in the freezer to chill. When they are cold, whip the cream until it is very stiff.


In another bowl combine softened cream cheese, sifted powdered Sucanat, half n half, vanilla and peanut butter. Mix this very well; it must be nice and smooth. Add about 1/3 of the whipped cream to this and mix well. Then fold this mixture into the last of the whipped cream. Spoon this mixture into the graham cracker crust. Drizzle chocolate syrup over the top and chill until cold. Serve and enjoy!


Graham Cracker Crust
Crystal Miller


1 ½ c. graham cracker crumbs

¼ c Sucanat

1/3 cup melted butter


Mix all ingredients together and press into the bottom and sides of a 9” pie plate. Set this in the refrigerator for a few minutes before pouring filling in. It will help the crust to solidify and not fall apart when filling. 



  1. Crystal,

    Oh my that pie looks delicious. I always love seeing what Emily comes up with to make.

    Have a blessed day today my friend.



  2. Wow, that looks fantastic. Thanks for sharing. I was sorry to read about your goats. Have a wonderful day!

  3. Hi! You said that Emily first made the graham crackers before she made the crust. Could you post the recipe for homemade graham crackers. My son and I love graham crackers so it would be fun to make them at home, (better for health and budget too)

  4. I'm not a fan of peanut butter, but that just looks so good I will have to try that for sure, and by the way I love your site ! have a great day, Sherry

  5. Good gravy, that looks just like MY kind of dessert!!! =D


  6. I am going to make this for a church gathering this Sunday., thank you for the wonderful idea. Please pray mine turns out as good as your.


Post a Comment

All messages are moderated. After approval your message will be posted. Thank you for your comments!! Crystal :)

Popular posts from this blog

Dishwasher Soap Sub

Canning Chicken Noodle-less Soup

Canning Beef Stew